SteadySharesSteadyShares
All guides
ExplainersAdvanced· 6 min read

Your broker is lending out your shares

The one thing to remember

Someone is being paid to lend your shares to people betting against them. Check whether it is you or your broker.

The question

Know what is happening to your assets while you sleep.

Figure

How Your broker is lending out your shares works, in one picture

1Short sellers need to borrow shares, and yours are available2The lender earns a fee, and it may not be you3While on loan, you are a creditor, not an owner4And you may lose your vote

The same argument as the text, as a chain. Each step is what makes the next one possible.

Figure

The fee you never see

Ask 100.06, you buy hereBid 100.00, you sell hereThe spread. That is the fee.

You buy at the ask and sell at the bid, so you are down the spread the instant you trade. In an illiquid stock it dwarfs any commission you thought you were avoiding.

  1. 1

    Short sellers need to borrow shares, and yours are available

    A short seller must borrow a share before selling it. That supply comes from long-term holders, via brokers and custodians. If you hold shares in a general account, they are a likely source.

  2. 2

    The lender earns a fee, and it may not be you

    Borrowers pay to borrow, sometimes a great deal for a heavily shorted stock. Many brokers keep most or all of that fee. Some share it. It is worth knowing which yours does, because on a hard-to-borrow name the sums are not trivial.

    'Free' brokerage is often funded partly here. Again: find the revenue line.

  3. 3

    While on loan, you are a creditor, not an owner

    You hold collateral and a claim, rather than the share itself. In the ordinary course this is invisible and harmless. If the borrower and the collateral both failed at once, it would not be.

  4. 4

    And you may lose your vote

    A lent share's voting right generally goes with it. If a contested vote matters to you, that is a real cost, and it is usually possible to opt out of lending.

Try it
The recovery curveInteractive
You lost
-50%
Gain needed just to get back
+100%
Losses and gains are not mirror images. Past about 50% the curve turns near vertical, which is the whole argument for never risking ruin.
You have got it when

You know whether your broker lends your shares, and who keeps the fee.

Read next

The bottom line

Someone is being paid to lend your shares to people betting against them. Check whether it is you or your broker.

See the 30 live screens

Every one shows its exact method, and the circumstances in which it is wrong. Free, and no account to look.