Tutorial: write an investment thesis
If you cannot write down why you own it and what would make you sell, you do not own an investment, you own a hope.
Produce a document that makes the sell decision for you, in advance, while you are still rational.
How write an investment thesis works, in one picture
The same argument as the text, as a chain. Each step is what makes the next one possible.
The order matters more than the maths
Cheapness is the last question. Ask it first and you produce a list of companies the market has given up on, and it is usually right.
- 1
One sentence: why this makes money
Not what the company does. Why it earns more than it costs to run, and why that will continue. If this sentence needs a paragraph, you do not understand the business yet.
- 2
One paragraph: why it is mispriced
Markets are mostly efficient, so if you think you have found a bargain, your first question should be: why has nobody else? There must be an answer. Perhaps it is too small for institutions, or the good news is two years out, or the market is extrapolating a temporary problem. If there is no answer, there is probably no bargain.
- 3
Three bullets: what would prove you wrong
This is the part everyone skips, and it is the only part that will save you money. Name the three specific developments that would mean the thesis is broken. Margin falls below X. The moat source disappears. The debt cannot be refinanced.
'The share price fell' is not on the list. Price is not evidence. The three things you wrote down are.
- 4
Then leave it alone and reread it in a year
Do not edit it as events unfold. The whole value of the document is that it records what you thought before you knew, which is the only honest measure of whether you are any good at this.
You have a one-page document per holding, dated, with three falsifiable conditions on it.
Read next
If you cannot write down why you own it and what would make you sell, you do not own an investment, you own a hope.
1,100+ companies across 17 exchanges, filtered on any combination of moat, valuation, growth and debt.
